Cognitive Biases and User Psychotypes in Interface Design: Creating an Effective Product

Read the Ukrainian version of this article here.

Understanding the hidden mechanisms of user thinking is the key to creating interfaces that are not only attractive but also intuitive and effective. In this article, we will explore how cognitive biases, psychotypes, and visual effects influence user interaction with your product and provide practical tips for improving your design.

Introduction: Why Even the Best Design Might Not Work

Modern interfaces are created with simplicity, intuitiveness, and convenience in mind. However, even the most beautiful and functional design may fail to achieve the desired effect if it does not consider the psychological aspects of user behaviour.

Reasons for Design Failure:

1 Insufficient Understanding of Users:

• If designers do not know who their users are, their needs, and pain points, the created interface may not meet the audience’s expectations.

2 Ignoring Cognitive Processes:

• The human brain does not always process information rationally. Ignoring this fact can lead to user overload or misunderstandings.

3 Lack of Testing:

• Without regular testing with real users, it is difficult to determine what works and what doesn’t.

Cognitive biases are natural brain mechanisms that simplify the processing of complex information but can distort reality. Considering these biases in design helps create more effective and appealing interfaces.

Example: Imagine an online store with a large assortment of products but lacking logical structure or clear navigation. Even if individual design elements look appealing, the complexity of finding the desired product can frustrate users and lead to a loss of interest.
Case Study: An e-commerce service faced low conversion rates due to a complicated menu structure. By optimizing navigation — simplifying the structure and adding visual highlights to key features — the service increased its conversion rate by 20% and improved user session duration by 15%.

Funnel conversion analysis: Improved navigation structure reduced drop-off rates and increased conversions between stages—optimization of elements enhanced user experience and overall site efficiency.

What Are Cognitive Biases and Why Are They Important in Design?

Cognitive biases are systematic thinking errors that arise from the brain’s simplification of information processing. They occur in situations where decisions need to be made quickly or under uncertainty.

Importance in Design:

1 Enhancing Interaction Efficiency:

• Understanding cognitive biases allows designers to create interfaces that account for users’ natural tendencies, making interactions more intuitive.

2 Reducing Cognitive Load:

• Optimized design helps users find necessary information and perform tasks more quickly without unnecessary effort.

3 Improving User Experience:

• Interfaces that consider psychological aspects create a more pleasant and satisfying experience for users.

How They Manifest in Interface Interaction:

1 Primacy Effect:

• Users pay attention to visually prominent elements. Important functions may go unnoticed if they do not stand out.

2 Example: If the “Buy” button blends into the website’s background, users will have a harder time finding it.

Expert Quote: ”Visual accents can guide users to the most important interface elements, improving overall interaction efficiency.” — Don Norman, UX Design Expert.

3 Focus on Simplicity:

• People choose what seems simpler, even if it’s not the optimal option.

4 Example: Users might opt for a simpler but less functional menu because it is easier to perceive.

Contrast between a complex and clean product card design. On the left — an overloaded card with difficult-to-locate key elements. On the right — a minimalist design highlighting the essentials: image, price, specifications, and CTA.

5 Habitual Patterns:

• Users look for familiar patterns (e.g., a magnifying glass for search or three lines for a menu).

6 Example: Using standard icons makes interface functions easier to understand.

Cognitive Biases in Design: Detailed Examples and Solutions

1 Decoy Effect
How it works:
Users tend to choose the “middle-ground” option if there is a less attractive alternative that emphasizes the advantages of another option.

Example:
On the Whimsical pricing page, there are three main plans:

• Free: Free access with basic features.
• Pro: $10/month per editor, includes advanced features (e.g., unlimited shared files and premium support).
• Org: $20/month per editor, adds enhanced security features and options for large teams.

In this case, the Org plan acts as a “decoy,” nudging users toward the Pro plan, which appears to be the most balanced in terms of price and features.

Solution:

• Add a decoy: Introduce a more expensive or less appealing plan to steer users toward the desired option.
• Ensure transparency: All plans should have clear and honest descriptions to allow users to make informed decisions.

Case Study:
Whimsical uses this approach in its pricing strategy to effectively increase subscriptions to the Pro plan. By structuring the pricing options correctly, the Pro plan became the most popular choice among users.

The Decoy Effect illustrated through Whimsical’s pricing plans. The middle-tier plan appears the most advantageous due to a well-structured visual hierarchy and the placement of additional features in the most expensive option.

2 Cognitive Overload
How it works:
When users face too much information or too many actions, their brains can’t cope, and they abandon the interaction.

Example:
A registration form with 20 fields. Users simply leave the page because the process seems too complicated.

Solution:

• Break Down the Process: Split complex processes into several steps with progress bars (e.g., “Step 1 of 3”).
• Minimize Fields: Show only essential fields. For example, ask for the user’s address only after order confirmation.
• Auto-Fill: Implement auto-fill where possible (e.g., address or phone number suggestions).
• Visual Cleanliness: Use a clean and minimalist design to avoid distracting users.

Multi-step form: breaking down a long registration process into steps reduces cognitive overload, making user interaction smoother.

3 Anchoring Bias
How it works:
People rely heavily on the first piece of information they see, even if it’s not optimal.

Example:
You see an initial discount offer: “Only $500 instead of $1000.” Even if another offer at $450 is better, the first offer seems more advantageous due to the emphasis on savings.

Solution:

• Use “anchors” to demonstrate benefits: For example, “Previously $50, now $35.”
• Allow users to compare options: This enables informed decisions.
• Additional Example: Display the recommended price next to the actual price to highlight the benefit of the purchase.

Expert Quote:
“Anchoring is a powerful tool that can significantly influence a user’s perception of a product’s value.” — Richard Thaler, Nobel Laureate in Economics

4 Rounded Corners: Visual Ease for Users
How it works:
Rounded shapes evoke a sense of comfort, reducing cognitive tension.

Example:
A “Buy” button with rounded edges appears friendlier than a button with sharp corners.

Solution:

• Use rounded corners: Apply them to buttons, input fields, and product cards.
• Combine rounded shapes with warm colors: This creates a “friendly” interface.
• Additional Example: Rounded icons in the navigation menu make the interface more modern and appealing.

Rounded corners reduce cognitive load, making buttons easier to perceive and interact with.

5 Loss Aversion
How it works:
People fear losing more than they desire to gain.

Example:
“Only 3 spots left at this price!” — such a message compels users to act quickly.

Solution:

• Use time or quantity restrictions: This creates a sense of urgency.
• Do not abuse this tactic: Messages must be honest to avoid user frustration.
• Additional Example: Displaying real-time stock levels (“Only 2 items left”) encourages users to purchase quickly.

Case Study:
A travel website uses messages about the number of room views, creating a sense of urgency and stimulating bookings.

Loss Aversion Effect on Booking. Messages about limited availability create urgency and encourage quick booking decisions.

User Psychotypes and Their Impact on Design

Users differ not only in demographic indicators but also in thinking styles. Understanding different psychotypes helps create interfaces that meet various needs and preferences.

User Types and Design Recommendations

Analysts
Characteristics:

• Love detail, choose options after thorough analysis.
• Value accuracy and reliability of information.

Solutions:

• Detailed Descriptions: Provide access to detailed descriptions, tables, and comparisons.
• FAQ Sections: Create comprehensive FAQ sections where complex questions can be answered.
• Filters and Sorting: Ensure flexible filtering and sorting options.
• Additional Resources: Offer links to detailed articles, analytical reports, or technical specifications.

Case Study: A professional service uses detailed user profiles and advanced search filters, allowing analytical users to quickly find necessary information.

Intuitives
Characteristics:

• Rely on first impressions, make quick decisions.
• Value aesthetics and simplicity.

Solutions:

• Simple Design: Use a simple and bright design with minimal elements.
• Visual Accents: Highlight key buttons and functions using color and size.
• Iconography: Use clear icons that facilitate information perception.
• Quick Access: Provide easy and fast access to main functions without unnecessary steps.

Expert Quote: “Simplicity in design allows intuitive users to quickly navigate and interact with the product.” — Steve Krug, author of “Don’t Make Me Think.”

Pragmatics
Characteristics:

• Focused on results, avoid unnecessary steps.
• Value efficiency and functionality.

Solutions:

• Minimal Actions: Ensure minimal actions to complete tasks. For example, use one-time actions (e.g., single entry of information).
• Straightforward UX: Use a straightforward and clear UX where each step logically follows the previous one.
• Automation: Automate routine processes so users can quickly achieve results.
• Quick Access to Functions: Place main functions in visible locations for quick access.

Emotional Users
Characteristics:

• React to colors, shapes, and emotional messages.
• Value aesthetics and the feeling of pleasant interaction with the interface.

Solutions:

• Positive Prompts: Add positive prompts (e.g., “You’re almost there!”).
• Bright Colors: Use bright colors and images that evoke trust and positive emotions.
• Micro-Animations: Use micro-animations to create a sense of a lively and interactive interface.
• Personalization: Allow users to personalize the interface to their preferences.

Expert Quote: “Emotional design creates a deeper connection between the user and the product, making interactions more pleasant and memorable.” — Bill Beaton, Emotional Design Specialist.

Table: User Psychotypes and Their Impact on Design

The table highlights key characteristics of different user psychotypes, their motivations, fears, and design recommendations. It helps designers better understand the audience’s needs and tailor interfaces to users’ thinking styles.

Infographic: Map of Cognitive Biases

For a deeper understanding of how cognitive biases influence user behavior, utilize this detailed infographic from Visual Capitalist. This map illustrates over 180 cognitive biases, categorizing them and demonstrating their impact on decision-making processes.

How It Helps Designers:

• In-Depth Understanding:
  Designers can see how biases affect user behavior.
• Practical Application:
  Using this information allows the creation of more effective interfaces.
• Improving Experience:
  Reducing users’ cognitive load by applying this data in practice.

Infographic: Cognitive Bias Codex.

Source: Visual Capitalist

Conclusion: How to Create a Design That Works

Cognitive biases and user psychotypes can become your best allies in creating a successful product. Here are key steps to achieve this goal:

Understanding the Audience:

• User Research:
  Conduct detailed user behavior research, including surveys, interviews, and analytics analysis.
• Persona Creation:
  Develop user personas that reflect different psychotypes and needs of your audience.

Testing and Optimization:

• A/B Testing:
  Use A/B testing to compare different design options and determine the most effective one.
• Usability Testing:
  Conduct usability testing to identify problem areas in user interactions with the interface.
• Feedback Collection:
  Actively collect and analyze user feedback for continuous product improvement.

Applying Psychological Principles:

• Visual Effects:
  Use visual effects like rounded corners, contrast, and highlights to reduce cognitive load and enhance usability.
• Emotional Design:
  Create emotionally appealing interfaces that evoke positive feelings and trust.

Continuous Learning and Adaptation:

• Trends and Innovations:
  Keep up with the latest trends in design and user psychology.
• Adaptation to Changes:
  Be ready to adapt the design according to changes in user behavior and needs.

Further Reading

• Cognitive Bias Codex by Visual Capitalist
• Center for Humane Technology
• Book: “Thinking, Fast and Slow” by Daniel Kahneman

Recommended Tools

For analyzing cognitive biases and creating intuitive interfaces, the following tools are recommended:

• Hotjar: For collecting user behavior data through heatmaps and session recordings.
• Google Analytics: For analyzing user behavior and gathering statistical data.
• Mixpanel: For analyzing conversion funnels, events, and behavioral patterns.
• Optimizely: For conducting A/B testing and optimizing design.
• VWO (Visual Website Optimizer): A tool for A/B testing and analyzing the performance of different design variations.

Did you enjoy the article?

Share it, leave your feedback, and share your thoughts!